HomeНаука и техникаRelated VideosMore From: Beyond The Routine

BtR - Fastest RX 580 at Ethereum Mining? 6 Top GPUs competes Part 2 of 7: ASUS ROG Strix T8G Top OC

363 ratings | 41958 views
We set out to test the top six RX 580 models offered by MSI, XFX, PowerColor, Sapphire, ASUS and GIGABYTE to see which one will be the king of kings in mining. The GPU Models we are putting up against each other are as followed: 1. MSI RX 580 Gaming X+ 8GB link: https://us.msi.com/Graphics-card/Radeon-RX-580-GAMING-X-Plus-8G.html 2. ASUS ROG Strix RX 580 TOP edition 8GB link: https://www.asus.com/us/Graphics-Cards/ROG-STRIX-RX580-T8G-GAMING/ 3. GIGABYTE AORUS RX 580 XTR 8G link: http://www.gigabyte.us/Graphics-Card/GV-RX580XTRAORUS-8G#kf 4. PowerColor Red Devil Golden Sample RX 580 8GB link: http://powercolor.com/us/products_features.asp?id=625 5. XFX GTR-S RX 580 Black Edition link: http://xfxforce.com/en-us/products/amd-radeon-rx-500-series/rx-580-gtr-8gb-dd-led-rx-580a8dbr6 6. Sapphire Nitro+ RX 580 Limited Edition link: http://sapphirenitro.sapphiretech.com/en/580-LE.html The software we use to monitor and test the GPUs are as followed: 1. TechPowerUp GPU-Z link: https://www.techpowerup.com/gpuz/ 2. HWinfo64 link: https://www.hwinfo.com/ 3. MSI Afterburner link: https://www.msi.com/page/afterburner If we have helped you in any way with our videos please consider a crypto currency donation: BTC = 1LqpAr1dT9s5iFKFhXUW6ED5XUB6LRucK4 ETH = 0xb2B72FC97d9DE6B01F943595E16a036D4380D0E0 LTC = LZy4yz5t8Kd4bZTfBhZtc3RoEwCDF88VqP https://www.facebook.com/beyondtheroutine/
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (157)
Milan Milasinovic (4 months ago)
Which one is best from these cards? Nice video bruh! :)
Smita (5 months ago)
I have seen this a couple times, since I have bought several different type of non-refferent RX 580 OC cards. Tomorrow I am expecting the shiittiest, but I still think it will make 30MH, MSI Armor. I have played with MSI Gaming X, Gaming X +, XFX RX580 GTS 8GB black edition(carbon-fiber design ones), and all give above 30.sth on the newer claymores now. The XFX is not with flashed BIOS< only switching to the 2nd BIOS they have installed from XFX factory. I am also waiting for a Nitro on Monday, which I am told from seller does above 30 to 31MH/s on ETH. So after playing with some RX580 cards myself, I think this review is a bit wrong. This is really cool comparison, and I like the video, I like discussing the package, the heatsink and fans, especially the memory type, but why set the CORE to 1375 and say there are memory errors. Not sure if the core would affect, but RX 580 Core sweet spot is about 1150 core on 2150 to 2175 memory (the core varies between 1130 to 1169). These setting allow for a nice undervolt, which actually may raise performance on ETH additionally, so testing ETH on core 1375 is not the best result shown in my opinion. New Claymore 11.6 sucked a few KH/s more nowadays, but still.
Jason wallace (6 months ago)
does this work on laptops? asus
#⃣Noticias e Fatos (6 months ago)
This is amazing!! I just gotten $ 1,200 USD from the Gigantic British Mineradora of Bitcoin WORLD MINIG she's paying from 27% to 30% a month ... British-based mining company See the Saving test I won in just 5 days !! It's a show, it's bombing = https://youtu.be/8Ry7onkXTPs
Mihajlo Jovic (7 months ago)
Which drivers?
RoelNicky (9 months ago)
pump up that core clock
AllMaxWorld (9 months ago)
Guys, I just get my Strix RX480 3 fan replace by asus because of fan failure for an RX580. As the one shown on the video. I try many time without moded bios , with moded bios. It all the time hashrate is 0. The power jumps to 50W and do not increase from that point. It never start hashing ... My old 480 was easlity 29.5-30mhs but the new one ... don't even start. Did someone has the similar issue?
David Wallis (9 months ago)
wow my Rx 570 4gb Red Devil cards do a stabl;e 29.5MHS at 75 watts, these special edition cards are pretty terrible !
Michal Janovský (9 months ago)
and becouse those people we pay triple the price for GPU and thats only if we manage to find some for sale .... thanks man, i realy love you now (sarcasm)
Robert RS (9 months ago)
Why you dont put links with BIOS mod here to download and test it ?
Роман (9 months ago)
"two USB 2.0b ports" ??? WTF? ))
ken jorgensen (10 months ago)
I have the same card but with Hynix memory, no errors running for weeks at 2200mhz, and hasching on 31 bong bong
Achmet Achmetsik (9 months ago)
I have the same card too with Hynix but I get only 22Mh/s. Can you help me?
BIG แฟมิลี่ (10 months ago)
Sorry, How much I can adjust highest Mhz of rx580 t8g 8gb?
pridon davitadze (10 months ago)
please someone tell me how many hash rate has radeon 580 .. thanks for help
pierre jean (10 months ago)
hi, can a MAX-overclocked GPU last same as the not overclocked one when maintaining the chip/mem low temp (let's say water or nitrogen )
SM96 (10 months ago)
Damn you miners!
NEO DON (11 months ago)
Hi I am a Sub and would like to know your opinion on my asus strixx RX580 Top overclock card, it only gets 19.500 Mh/s in claymore mining, should I send it back to Newegg for a replacement?
MomoKIA (11 months ago)
Mine out of box only 20mh/s. Is it normal? Damn!
Have you try this for mining monero?
Michael Urie (1 year ago)
hey BtR can you help me with a stable overclock setting without bios flash for an asus strix rx 580's mining ethereum??? please ! and thank you.
AmbSwizag (1 year ago)
I failed to see the 'usb 2.0b' ports he mentioned..
Shutter Eff3ct (10 months ago)
LOL
Rakly3 (1 year ago)
they're a myth!
Matej Skerjanc (1 year ago)
hey there Beyond The Routine, could you publish the bios or at least the straps? My asus is not really meddled with much I got like 27mhs per. So your help is appreciated:)
trinh huy (1 year ago)
gigabyte rx 580 gaming 8G good choice??
fangdan fangdan (1 year ago)
Can you share this bios to me? I have my 8 1070 working right now. but i really need this bios
Sunny D (1 year ago)
Fantastic vid mate, What was the exact bios flash configs you used for this card, ASUS ROG Strix T8G Top OC, and would it work for the ASUS ROG Strix T8G OC version? Any info would be appreciated :) Thanks
Tuxnor (8 months ago)
Running all my RX580 T8G at 30.5 mh/s stabile , you need to patch the driver with AMD/ATI Pixel Clock Patcher, also the new drivers from AMD has compute as an option for mining :)
Sunny D (1 year ago)
Beyond The Routine hey mate thanks for the reply, do you have any advice for The same GPU - Asus RX580 OC Strix with HYNIX memory as it doesn't seem go work I have 3 and they all seem to unstably cap out at 23.5 using the same overclocks crashing the sytem. at stock they get 20.5 :( how can I fix this to get 29.3 like my other samsung memory GPUs. also the Hynix has an additional timing 0:2250 do I copy over the value to this field also?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
All we did was copying the 1750 timing value into the 2000 timing. And yes it works with all versions of ASUS ROG Strix 8GB versions.
fangdan fangdan (1 year ago)
Currently I have 7 asus 580 strix ,2 xfx 580 4gb and one gigabyte 580 8gb. Can they work together on two mining rig? Will 4gb have a worse result than the 8GB?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Yes they can all work together without issues. If you flash the bios correctly (4GB and 8GB have different bios mods) then you should get 29+ MH/s from both 4GB and 8GB cards. Just remember to get the voltage/clock settings in whichever software you use (Afterburner, Wattman, etc.) individually.
fangdan fangdan (1 year ago)
Is it possible for asus card to have 30 mh/s?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
It is possible but not stable. We have never come across an ASUS card that mines at 30+ MH/s stably, but "Hercules" are out there...let us know if you find one.
Bitcoin México (1 year ago)
Hi, I have the Z270X UD3 Cres that serves me to mine?
Bitcoin México (1 year ago)
thanks
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Yes, that motherboard will handle 6+ GPUs.
Johnny (1 year ago)
Where are you magicing these graphics cards from. They are sold out everywhere
Johnny (1 year ago)
They are sold out everywhere except the once that are being resold for $600 each. sadface
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
We buy most of them from sites like Newegg and Amazon, but occasionally we've been known to shop internationally and direct.
dawe dast (1 year ago)
next time do something with audio level.... i cant hear u and its irritating me (no i cant +++volume)
dawe dast (1 year ago)
Beyond The Routine so in your editing software do first part audio gain +10, second part audio is OK and last part also audio gain +10..... keep it up I'm curious for sapphire cards
dawe dast (1 year ago)
Beyond The Routine till 3:00 too quiet... 3:00+ too loud (if I add volume on start ).... 6:00 too quiet... I'm gonna fix audio levels for you to see example
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
are you referring to the entire video or a certain portion?
lenso010 (1 year ago)
you say people disappointed bcs msi does 30.25 instead of 31. How big is that difference in mining business ? I was planing to buy something performing at 28. I'm confused
lenso010 (1 year ago)
awesome
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
both should, at least 28-30
lenso010 (1 year ago)
XTR model right not the Gaming 8G model?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
you should buy them all, they will all give you 30 MH/s hashrate.
lenso010 (1 year ago)
I found 5pcs of these.GIGABYTE RX580 Gaming 8G DDR5. I want to buy this before they are gone. Also 3pcs GIGABYTE RX580 Aorus XTR 8G available to buy it now. Any opinion about these models based on performance, overclocking , undervolting hash rate to expect? Which one should I buy now?
0Leericks0 (1 year ago)
dofference between oc and oc TOP edition ?? is it the same same ...or not .the Oc edition is still good ?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
regular OC is still good, but the TOP OC edition is their special "limited edition" but they don't call it "limited edition".
Oxxygen (1 year ago)
Basicly all rx 470,480,570 are sold out here in sweden. lol
uibis (1 year ago)
Beyond The Routine sure but I rather pay 70% more and get 2x performance. I got what looks to be one of the last 480 today. 3 cards in my rig now. But it will be kind of a patch work later with 470, 480, next 3 cards will be 570 or 580. Depends on what your guide comes up with 😁 Thanks for being original and awesome
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
You can mine with 460 and 560 4GB editions, get about 10-15 MH/s each in Ethereum.
Cadnee Mountai (1 year ago)
Hey man thanks for making the video, what BIOS did you use when you flashed the card? I've been looking around and yours gets the best result.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
we use Polaris Bios Editor, copy the 1750 timing to the 2000 timing.
Cadnee Mountai (1 year ago)
Beyond The Routine how did you go about changing the timings, which ones specifically?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
We mod our own bios, and mainly we just adjust the timing.
fgrzejszczyk (1 year ago)
@Beyond The Routine Hi, cool series! Would you happen to know something more about Sapphire rx5804gb with hynix memory?
fgrzejszczyk (1 year ago)
Thanks!
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
simple, copy the timing from the 1500 to the 1625/1750/2000 in the first set of timings. Save the modded rom file with a different name, then flash the modded bios to the card. And then give the following settings a try: undervolt by -96mV, set core clock to 1150 MHz and vRAM clock to 2050 MHz. You should then get about 30 MH/s.
fgrzejszczyk (1 year ago)
it's Nitro+ and I am looking for bios settings that would take me from 24 up, in particular. But if you have any how to: bios settings tips or could make a video, that would be great! I know the process, that I need to back up my original settings and loading .roms but I don't really understand how to change the parameters to make the card most effective.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Are you referring to the Pulse series or the Nitro+ series? What specifically would you like to know about it?
Javier Abadie (1 year ago)
Hi man. I have 2 rigs. One with 5 x RX570 AORUS 4 GB. And another with 1 x 570 AORUS 4 GB and 1 x RX 480 MSI Gaming X. All have the bios mod. On the second rig with the 2 GPU (570 + 480) I can't install the drivers. On the first I have Win 10, on the second Windows 7. So... how I can install and work with that 2 gpu on Windows 7 64 bits? Thanks.
Javier Abadie (1 year ago)
I using DDU before. I install win10 and it works. I don't know whats the problem with my windows 7. I supose the bios mod is undetected by windows 7 if you modded on windows 10 previously.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
The OS shouldn't have anything to do with your issues. We have rigs here running in Win7 as well as Win10. Try using DDU to remove your driver completely and install the driver again if you haven't tried that.
Javier Abadie (1 year ago)
Exactly that both. I will try now with Windows 10 (I flashed the bios on W10)
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Which driver are you installing for your second rig with the 570 + 480? 17.5.1 (and 17.5.2) should not have any issues.
Giovanni Forastieri (1 year ago)
when will part 3 come out? i am anxious. you're doing a good job :)
SuperGoldee (1 year ago)
Liviu Nita hello friend, can you give me your email, I have the same vcard 570 gig 4gb, want to ask you some questions...
Liviu Nita (1 year ago)
I have a Gigabyte 570 who's pulling out 30 Mh/s at almost half the price. That's why he's saying it's not the best mining GPU.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Thank you for being such a loyal audience, we hope your patience will be rewarded. Since this is a competition between 6 of the top model RX 580 GPUs, we are merely saying the results from the ASUS card was less promising. From our experience, ASUS makes great gaming GPUs but not always the best mining GPUs.
Max Wicked (1 year ago)
I'm just here refreshing my subscriptions, waiting for the upload for the past 3 hours. Also, why do you say that this isn't good for mining? Its only 1mh/s than the MSI version.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Thanks, it will be released tonight (might be late late tonight but it will be tonight).
- FreeSpirit - (1 year ago)
Top 👍Thanks
Hanson Lim (1 year ago)
Is the msi gaming x plus rx 580 compatible with the g1 gaming sniper b6 motherboard?
Hanson Lim (1 year ago)
Alright man, thanks for the tip!
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
one time that happened to me and it turns out I forgot to plug the power to the video card lol. That is strange, the only think I can think of is that your CPU probably has built-in graphics, like many Intel CPUs do now days, and somehow in your bios it is set to be the primary, so try to plug your monitor into the video I/O on the motherboard and see if you get any video signal. If that's the case, then just change the bios setting to auto detect on the graphics source or set it to PCIe.
Hanson Lim (1 year ago)
What's confusing is that i recently bought this new RX 580 gaming x+ from MSI. And my PC turns on, the only thing that doesn't was my monitor. I have: 16 GB DDR 3 CX 500 PSU G1 Gaming sniper B6 Mother Board And of course the VGA itself, so why doesn't my monitor turn on..?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
there is no info to indicate that it would not. It should be compatible, even older chipset mobos work with the MSI Gaming X+ RX 580.
alvin mayer (1 year ago)
put a graph to compare on the end of the video add price/performance and power consumption etc. so viewer can easily see which one is the best
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
We plan on doing all that in the final episode of the series, charts and all, it's gonna be informative!
Vasilios Tourtoulis (1 year ago)
Great channel. What was the power draw on the final setting for this card? Could you squeeze out a little more hashing power by not lowering the voltage?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
final power draw according to GPU-Z and HWinfo was at 124W but we believe we can decrease that further by using other tuning softwares. MSI Afterburner has a limitation on the core voltage adjustment.
Rod (1 year ago)
videos ideas: pools comparison, Claymore command line unusual commands... , .bat edit, how to Claymore restart it self after power interruption...
Rod (1 year ago)
If you have a opportunity can you show the graphic card with the faults in the GPU memory, showing when it starts not to be good, just one quick exemple.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
will try to do that in our next video :)
Rod (1 year ago)
I'm going to Taiwan Monday 5th Jun, to buy 18 Graphic cards, if you need some information from there please let me know.
Rod (1 year ago)
would be nice talk more about it in a video
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
yes we set all PCIe to 1x in the bios. The issue was driver related, we fixed it using the hybrid-driver method
Rod (1 year ago)
Decided ASUS PRIME Z270-A, 7 PCI (need downgrade the PCIs speeds to accept 7 cards) I think I saw one of your videos you saying about one card did not work in the Rig, did you tried downgrade the PCIs speed on Bios?
Rod (1 year ago)
I mean graphic board.. mother board I'm planing to buy AsRock H81 Pro BTC Motherboard, but I will certainly consider your suggestion, this is a good idea to do videos ... same graphic board different mother boards, put on the list :)
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
are you referring to motherboard suggestion? I would suggest this one: https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813130997, will go nicely with your MSI RX 480 Gaming X
Rod (1 year ago)
Very nice! Your subscribers will jump from 900 to 2 thousand very quick.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
That would be much desired my friend, thanks!
Khalid Alamimi (1 year ago)
thk u
MrPsycho (1 year ago)
Awesome video! Asus disappointed me a little bit, as I was expacting ~31MH/s. Also it would be super cool if you create sheet (eg. google docs) with all the results, pros and cons at the end of series. I hope to see more video, keep it up!
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Thanks! Great suggestions. We do plan on publishing all the settings and the bios at the end of the series. We are working hard to bring you more videos, so stay tuned!
Moises Cano Ortiz (1 year ago)
Good afternoon excellent video I follow him for a long time and recently acquired some 6 xfx 580 could tell us which are the optimal values to reach that mine and how much power the graphic consumes. thank you very much.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Let us know which software you would like to use to make the adjustments and we will either make a video on it or point you to the videos or guides available. The general goal is, regardless which tool you use, you want to achieve the highest stable hashrate where the core clock is the lowest and the vRAM clock is the highest. We usually start the core clock at 1050 MHz and go up from there until it's at the point where you are no longer gaining any hashrate. For the vRAM, we start at 2000 MHz and go up until the GPU becomes unstable and then set it to just under that. We also try to undervolt the core as much as possible. The combination of lower core voltage and core clock will reduce the power consumption and temperature, while increasing the vRAM clock will do the opposite.
Moises Cano Ortiz (1 year ago)
You could pass some video or manual where you explain how you do what you tell me.
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
You won't see alot of difference in mining capabilities between the GTS and the GTR, but GTR does come with better cooling
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
have you been able to get them to mine at the 31 MH/s hashrate stable? Generally, the hierarchy of XFX RX 500 series goes like this: RS<GTS<GTR<GTR-S. However, these are ratings for how well they game, not how well they mine. Manufacturers do put better components into building higher end GPUs, like bigger heatsink or higher bin chips, however, because Ethereum mining is heavy on the vRAM and not so much on the GPU core, it mainly comes down to how overclock friendly the RAM in the video card is. I recommend doing the most you can with them, try different core and vRAM settings, and find that sweet spot for your batch of GPUs. If you need help, message us :)
Moises Cano Ortiz (1 year ago)
Okay, but for the moment I have bought 12 cards of this type and I have to exploit them, I can not return them. What do you recommend me ?
Possible the best card for the mining of etherium so far
victoromania (1 year ago)
we dont see how you get 30.3...by modimg or just overcloking mem?...video sucks...volume to low...
victoromania (1 year ago)
Beyond The Routine now all its fine...best regards...
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Thanks for your feedback, we will work on boosting our volume. The 30.3 hashrate is for the MSI RX 580 Gaming X+ we tested in Part 1 of 7. The setting to get to that is as followed: Core clock to 1200 MHz, vRAM clock to 2200 MHz, and we down-volted the core by -96mV to 1.031V. And yes, we did mod the bios by copying the 1750 timing to the 2000 timing. Hope that helps.
Online Earning Ideaz (1 year ago)
Hi Bro your videos are very helpful. I need your help I want to built an ethereum mining rig please help me which cards I should chose, where from I should buy with lowest cost (good performance) including all hardware. I need a complete video tutorial how to fix it and which software works for ethereum, Zcash, Pacal etc. mining. I want to start mining help me out bro & It'll helpful for others too. Oblige please.
Online Earning Ideaz (1 year ago)
Thanks for reply
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
I think what you are asking for already exist on the net. Almost all of our rigs are different because we shop for the cheapest parts which meets the minimum requirement of running a 6+GPU mining rig. We can make a video tutorial outlining the bare minimum you need to build a rig if that would help? In regards to bios modding and flashing, there are so many great videos on YouTube already, we won't want to over-crowd that space. We like using Claymore as the mining software, but people have great success with others like Simple Mining, ethOS, etc.
Jason Fan (1 year ago)
Hey bro, I recently wanna buy GPU card. which one is the best choice you think so far?
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
thanks! we love our audience.
Jason Fan (1 year ago)
by the way, I love your channel!
Jason Fan (1 year ago)
Thanks, bro. I am planning to get my first GPU mining rig recently. It's hard to get GPU in the US market now...
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
RX 480s are fast and easy to mine with.
Jason Fan (1 year ago)
I can get MSI RX470, R480, RX570 and RX580. Which is the best choice for GPU mining?
Peter A (1 year ago)
damn sucks the ROG Strix couldnt even get 30 mh pretty disappointing, also doesnt this consume more ppower usage /wattage then other 580s as well? :o
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
We are equally disappointed, and yes it is slower at mining and consumes more power...
Peter A (1 year ago)
Bro. Is nextwarehouse a good site to buy GPUs from? let me know bro. keep up the vids, just subbed to u earlier 2day thanksfor the replies man ur awesome keep up the work
Peter A (1 year ago)
https://www.amazon.com/PowerColor-AXRX-580-8GBD5-3DHDV2-OC/dp/B0711QH8ZS/ref=sr_1_1?s=pc&rps=1&ie=UTF8&qid=1496305186&sr=1-1&keywords=rx+580&refinements=p_85%3A2470955011 you think this worth "pre ordering" :( only freaking rx580 i can find man, and idk how good hash rate is on it, cant find no videos on these powercolor 580s :( (no eth mining videos with them) :(
Beyond The Routine (1 year ago)
Thanks for subscribing! We've never shopped at nextwarehouse but if they have inventory for any RX470/480/570/580 their pricing don't seem too outrageous.
Adam Anderson (1 year ago)
But good news. ETH is at all time highs.
Adam Anderson (1 year ago)
Ouch that's a downer. But great video!
Adam Anderson (1 year ago)
So I thought I was finally going to be able to build my first rig I started ordering and apparently I cannot find any Red Dragon RX570S. Complete downer. But enough about that I'm staying optimistic let's see what this beautiful card can do!

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.